At the Central APA conference, I am giving a talk on violence in popular culture. I examine how violence is portrayed in superhero media, where violence is often seen as a useful tool. Different ethical approaches are also reflected in different portrayals of superheroes: Batman has rules, but some other portrayals are more aligned with utilitarian or virtue ethics. I argue that our media reveals different perspectives on the costs of violence. Looking at these examples of superhero media reveals different messages about the value of nonviolence.